Six States to Appeal California Egg Law Decision

SIX STATES TO APPEAL CALIFORNIA EGG LAW DECISION

Attorneys from six states that originally brought a lawsuit against California for Proposition 2 and AB 1437, laws which regulate cage standards for egg-laying hens in both California and any state which produces eggs sold in California, are back to appeal a decision made by a lower federal court to toss the lawsuit. The lawsuit claimed that California was seeking to illegally regulate U.S. Commerce by enforcing its laws on outside producers, but the lower court judge threw it out, ruling that "private egg producers in states outside California were the only interests being represented by the states, and that was not enough to merit standing through parens patriae." Parens patriae is a doctrine that grants states legal standing to intervene on behalf of citizens in need of protection or help. In this case, they argued that the economic well-being of their people was being damaged. Those six states - Oklahoma, Iowa, Kentucky, Alabama, Nebraska, and Missouri - have seen their egg markets negatively affected by these outrageous laws. Both producers and consumers of egg products in the states that do business with California can clearly see a difference in the soaring prices. [caption id="attachment_3177" align="aligncenter" width="200"]Grocery store display egg display in California Grocery store egg display in California[/caption] Proposition 2 and AB 1437 were pushed strongly by Humane Society of the United States and lawmakers under the implication that they would “protect California consumers from the deleterious, health, safety, and welfare effects of the sale and consumption of eggs derived from egg-laying hens that are exposed to significant stress that may result in increased exposure to disease pathogens including salmonella.” No scientific study found that to be the case, however. Cage size and stocking density had no correlation to disease or stress levels. J. Andrew Hirth, the deputy general counsel for Missouri Attorney General Chris Koster and who authored the appeal, had this to say about AB 1437's intended purpose:

"(It) was not to protect public health but rather to protect California’s egg farmers from the market effects of Prop 2 by ‘leveling the playing field’ for out of state egg producers.”

California consumes 9 billion eggs per year, but 45% of that total comes from out-of-state producers. The six Attorneys General should be applauded for their unwavering commitment to fighting these unjust laws that affect the entire country.

NEWSLETTER

DONATE

Please consider donating to Protect The Harvest.

Donate Today

FRIEND OF THE LAND

Nominate a Friend of the Land.

Nominate a Friend

Events

  • 2021 IAFE Convention

    Join us at the 2021 IAFE Convention. The dates include Monday, November 29, 2021 - Tuesday, November 30, 2021 We would love to see you there!


  • NAFB Trade Talk-Convention

    Join us at the NAFB Trade Talk-Convention. The dates include Wednesday, November 17, 2021 - Friday, November 19, 2021 We would love to see you there!


  • Commodity Classic

    Join us at the Commodity Classic. The dates include Thursday, March 10, 2022 - Saturday, March 12, 2022 We would love to see you there!


Events

  • Starts: Monday, November 29, 2021

    2021 IAFE Convention

    Join us at the 2021 IAFE Convention. The dates include Monday, November 29, 2021 - Tuesday, November 30, 2021 We would love to see you there!

    2 months from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Wednesday, November 17, 2021

    NAFB Trade Talk-Convention

    Join us at the NAFB Trade Talk-Convention. The dates include Wednesday, November 17, 2021 - Friday, November 19, 2021 We would love to see you there!

    2 months from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Thursday, March 10, 2022

    Commodity Classic

    Join us at the Commodity Classic. The dates include Thursday, March 10, 2022 - Saturday, March 12, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    5 months from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Friday, October 29, 2021

    Cedar City Livestock & Heritage Festival

    Join us at the Cedar City Livestock & Heritage Festival. The dates include Friday, October 29, 2021 - Saturday, October 30, 2021 We would love to see you there!

    1 month from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Wednesday, October 27, 2021

    2021 FFA National Convention

    Join us at the 2021 FFA National Convention. The dates include Wednesday, October 27, 2021 - Friday, October 29, 2021 We would love to see you there!

    4 weeks from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Friday, November 12, 2021

    American Agri-Women Conference

    Join us at the American Agri-Women Conference. The dates include Friday, November 12, 2021 - Saturday, November 13, 2021 We would love to see you there!

    1 month from now
    Website Location