The SCOTUS Effect on WOTUS

THE SCOTUS EFFECT ON WOTUS

The recent loss of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia marks the loss of a dedicated public servant and man who was widely considered to be one of the most respected legal minds, whose engaging perspective on the law made him extremely consequential in many matters.

One lesser known, but far-reaching, issue that will be impacted by Justice Scalia’s absence is wetland regulation. The nature of Scalia’s replacement will have major implications on the highly controversial Waters of the U.S. rule, otherwise known as WOTUS. WOTUS defines which waters (rivers, lakes, streams, marshes, and more) fall under the jurisdiction of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Army Corps of Engineers. Many state and agriculture leaders feel that WOTUS is simply a power grab by the federal government to control more land. Members of Congress have come out in strong opposition to the EPA’s handling of this rule. In fact, EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy recently experienced severe criticism from members of the House Agriculture Committee, who blasted her for the agency’s actions which the Committee claimed have caused hardships for farmers in their states.

From the Des Moines Register:

“Despite assurances they are protected, farm and livestock groups fear that the rule overreaches by expanding the scope of "navigable waters" protected by the act — potentially subjecting ditches, stream beds and self-made ponds on their property to new oversight that would require costly environmental assessments and permits.”

These fears have gradually increased over the years. In fact, the Supreme Court has ruled on many cases this century involving wetlands challenges. According to Politico, Justice Scalia often wrote the majority opinion on these rulings. Perhaps the most prominent of these cases was Rapanos v. United States, in which it was determined that the Army Corps of Engineers was too overreaching in its authority over waters.

This case was thought to have defined what navigable waters meant, that is until the current administration’s attempts to re-define and expand on that rule. Undoubtedly, the WOTUS expansions will make their way to the Supreme Court. By the time that occurs, we could potentially have a new Supreme Court Justice in place. Devoid of Scalia’s presence on the Court, it will be interesting to see what the new Justice’s take and influence will be on this issue.

Will it be a Justice who falls in line with the Obama administration’s often-extreme advances on environmental legislation? Someone who sides with Gina McCarthy and the EPA on expansive regulation of farmland? That remains to be seen, but the feeling among many is that the balance of how the Court views water rules has been shifted. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit issued a nationwide stay in 2015 against the enforcement of the Clean Water Act for which WOTUS applies. With the Supreme Court being almost evenly divided on the controversy, a 4-4 decision would uphold this lower court’s ruling. But, if the Court were to add a liberal Justice before this ruling is made, a 5-4 decision would have significant impact on WOTUS moving forward and grant the federal government even more control over the day-to-day lives of America’s family farms and ranches.

NEWSLETTER

DONATE

Please consider donating to Protect The Harvest.

Donate Today

FRIEND OF THE LAND

Nominate a Friend of the Land.

Nominate a Friend

Events

  • Gilroy Rodeo

    Join us at the Gilroy Rodeo. The dates include Friday, August 12, 2022 - Sunday, August 14, 2022 We would love to see you there!


  • CALIFORNIA'S RICHE$T

    Join us at the CALIFORNIA'S RICHE$T. The dates include Saturday, August 6, 2022 - Sunday, August 7, 2022 We would love to see you there!


  • NHRA US NATIONALS-Indianapolis

    Join us at the NHRA US NATIONALS-Indianapolis. The dates include Wednesday, August 31, 2022 - Monday, September 5, 2022 We would love to see you there!


Support Protect the Harvest by Purchasing PTH Swag

Events

  • Starts: Friday, August 12, 2022

    Gilroy Rodeo

    Join us at the Gilroy Rodeo. The dates include Friday, August 12, 2022 - Sunday, August 14, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    1 month from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Saturday, August 6, 2022

    CALIFORNIA'S RICHE$T

    Join us at the CALIFORNIA'S RICHE$T. The dates include Saturday, August 6, 2022 - Sunday, August 7, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    1 month from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Wednesday, August 31, 2022

    NHRA US NATIONALS-Indianapolis

    Join us at the NHRA US NATIONALS-Indianapolis. The dates include Wednesday, August 31, 2022 - Monday, September 5, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    2 months from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Thursday, August 11, 2022

    Missouri Fox Trotting Horse Event

    Join us at the Missouri Fox Trotting Horse Event. The dates include Thursday, August 11, 2022 - Saturday, August 13, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    1 month from now
    Website Location
  • Starts: Tuesday, June 28, 2022

    NAITC National Conference

    Join us at the NAITC National Conference. The dates include Tuesday, June 28, 2022 - Friday, July 1, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    18 hours ago
    Website Location
  • Starts: Saturday, August 6, 2022

    St. Puppy's Day

    Join us at the St. Puppy's Day. The dates include Saturday, August 6, 2022 - Saturday, August 6, 2022 We would love to see you there!

    1 month from now
    Website Location